While perhaps true, that leaves Cheryl alone in the knowledge of what shes been through. Based on FBI crime data, Poughkeepsie is not one of the safest communities in America. The person who is framed looks absolutely nothing like him. Menu. Horror is often the ideal vehicle for up-and-coming independent directors looking to prove themselves. He also severed the foot of many-a-corpse for his fetishes, before disposing the corpses in water bodies. Many show footage of Cheryl Dempsey, a young woman kidnapped by the Butcher and held prisoner for eight years before she is found by police along with the tapes. While the abuse Cheryl endures during the film is much more extreme, it follows similar patterns. Every beautiful stretch of woodlands becomes the perfect spot to hide a dismembered body. Soon after the interview, she commits suicide and in a note states her undying love for her "master". I've been meaning to watch this for years, so after seeing your post I went ahead and checked it out. Clearly, the faux-documentary tactics John Erick Dowdle used for his movie have been effective, even in an era where audiences are internet-savvy and all but guaranteed to have seen plenty of mockumentaries. This strategy has reaped rich dividends, and the name of the movie has been consistently doing the rounds on blogs all over the internet, despite the canceled release 7 years ago. The mockumentary ends with one officer speculating about Eds whereabouts. "The Poughkeepsie Tapes" represented a major genre shifter for writer-director John Erick Dowdle and his brother, co-producer Drew Dowdle. His victim had same kind of Stockholm syndrome and was held in the box under his bed. They are filled with depravity. Though the killer fled, he left behind nearly 800 videotapes, that not only show him torturing and killing his victims, but even how he pursues and stalks them. With the successive kidnappings and murders, the authorities begin to invest more resources in the case. Underneath, it's one of the scariest films ever made. Im scared extremely easily so knowing that this film isnt real makes me feel a little better. It was shot by utilizing both the mockumentary and found-footage styles of moviemaking. That puts it in impressive company that includes "I Spit on Your Grave," "Sal," "The Texas Chain Saw Massacre," "The Evil Dead," "The Exorcist," and "Possession." I dont want to say that this film is about Hooker's case but there is something common and it makes this movie more realistic. The video quality of the footage does seem like it has been shot by an amateur, and some scenes do look real. After his execution, the cops receive a mail from the killer, telling them that they have missed a body, and it is soon clear that they had the wrong man. It hurt my voice; it was miserably depressing. No, The Poughkeepsie Tapes is not based on a true story. Unfortunately, she kills herself two weeks after the interview. Has anyone discovered what the hidden sign language throughout the movie means? During the raid, they found over 800 videotapes that showed a record of the killers murders in all their horrifying details. While the Water Street Butcher does kill her, the actual death scene feels like an afterthought compared to the sheer suspenseful terror of a scene that doesn't have the killer touch her at all. Similarly, the nature of the crimes committed, including violent sexual, physical torture, and necrophilia, do face an uncanny similarity to the cases of several serial killers. As a mark of what's considered "low-budget" in the entertainment industry, the article looks at films made for $500k $3 million. If she had just been good, he wouldnt have had to hurt her. Cheryls story is one of triumph over incredible odds. He made the victims believe that they were his slaves, and even explained what he was going to do with them, before the torture began. The Dowdle brothers ensured that the film will look as authentic as possible by hiring little-known actors and using cheap cameras to film the found-footage scenes. Many critics praised The Poughkeepsie Tapes for its disturbing atmosphere, the performances by the largely-unknown members of the cast, and gripping storyline. [Editorial] Films To Ruin Your Day: This Little Piggy Went To Market, [Editorial] Films To Ruin Your Day: Submission & Abuse, [Editorial] Films To Ruin Your Day: Getting Fucked To Death, [Editorial] Films To Ruin Your Day: Vomiting & Genital Mutilation, [Editorial] In Her Eyes: Tasya Vos in Possessor (2020), [Editorial] In Her Eyes: Sara Lowes in Witchfinder General (1968), [Editorial] In Her Eyes: Helen Lyle in Candyman (1992), [Editorial] Lorraine Warrens Clairvoyant Gift, [Editorial] Sally Hardesty in The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (1974), [Editorial] Margaret Robinson: Hammers Puppeteer. Is my ultimate goal to spark the cycle of humiliation and punishment by revealing secrets Ive kept deeply hidden and exposing the pieces of my life Ive been told to believe are shameful? No, Megan is Missing is not real. SPOILERS AHEAD. As a result, the film was banned until now, nearly a decade later. The big distinction between them is Francois never kept a detailed video record of his crime. This is when Ed starts hunting for prostitutes while dressed as a police officer. The most interesting inspiration for the Poughkeepsie Tapes seems to have been drawn from this case. William was born in Denton, TX and currently resides in Austin. He murders and mutilates her boyfriend Tim and imprisons Cheryl in his basement, abusing her sexually, physically and psychologically as his "slave". Powered by WordPress.com VIP. When I moved out of my parents house, I began dating men who were mean to me. When he returned, he somehow managed to establish contact with her. Cookies help us deliver our Services. His necrophiliac activities continued until the late stages of decomposition, or until the corpse was destroyed by wild animals. Dowdle was more inspired by the original "Halloween," which helped teach him about the impact of first-person killer POV. https://imgur.com/a/yEJjlY6. The videos chronicle a decade-long work of the psychopath, and each video is recorded by the killer himself. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. She appears gaunt as her cheekbones sink deep into the confines of her skull. Also, the part where the cops take the help of the infamous killer Ted Bundy, who advises them to wait at the locations of the disposed bodies for the killer to show up, was a real occurrence in this case. Towards the end of the movie, the filmmakers apparently interview Cheryl Dempsey, the only victim that the killer lets go. The film justifies the killer's theatricality, however, via an interview with a vaudeville performer who explains that wearing a mask makes it easier for someone to disassociate from their actions and do increasingly worse things. The movie consists of several tapes which have been combined, each of which has been shot by the murderer from a hand-held camera, beginning from the moment he begins stalking his victims, to kidnapping, torturing, and killing them. She says that the Butcher loved her and will come back for her, and later kills herself two weeks later. This effectively implies that Foley was innocent, and the real killer is still out there. Victoria Dempsey "She kept covering her eyes, whispering "please take me home, please take me home, please take me home." a week later I got her outta there and I brought her home. Im sure other films are technically more violent and of course I havent seen every movie, but something about The Poughkeepsie Tapes seemed to resonate with me. As Nightmare on Film Street put it, "Some said that it was because it was too scary. Mary Harrons American Psycho has had a strange and convoluted path to its current position as a lauded part of the American horror canon, Motherhood isnt always a choice. He exercises a control over her mind that is so absolute and so brutally enforced that when she's finally rescued, she's terrified of ever accidentally saying something her listener doesn't want to hear. I still have a relationship with him, but it is strained. The hair is a totally different color and style, his face is totally different, and he's much older. R/HORROR, known as Dreadit by our subscribers is the premier horror entertainment community on Reddit. It definitely makes sense and for how much they really do praise him for being such a good serial killer that it makes sense that hed be able to fool everybody and make this documentary. As they investigate, the cops spot similarities in the victims, realizing that they are dealing with a serial killer. ", Originally, Stacy Chbosky told John Norman for his book "Welcome to Our Nightmares,"she planned to stay behind the scenes of "The Poughkeepsie Tapes." Although I'm still unclear on what he did to the married couple. So by creating this documentary and editing the narrative in such a way, he's actually causing Cheryl's death and harm after returning home to be seen by the dumb police and by the audience to be the fault of Cheryl herself when he is actually the one to blame. "The Poughkeepsie Tapes" is grueling viewing; that emotional impact doesn't necessarily stem from an onslaught of gore, however. Its my favourite horror movie but I haven't think about it this way before. She suffers everything from PTSD to Stockholm syndrome as she talks about the love that her captor proclaimed for her. But the part that throws me out was the fake pathologist. Is it based on a true story? For eighteen years, I lived in fear, wondering what I would inadvertently do that day to make him mad and how harsh the punishment would be. The police find Cheryl inside a coffin, highly malnourished and with irreparable psychological and physical injuries. Most of the crimes occurred between the years 1968 to 1994, when the killer couple was finally arrested. The torture scenes horrified me, but more than anything, the final interview with Cheryl Dempsey really had me stuck in my seat. However, the character is not based on any real-life person or events, and is entirely fictional. The Poughkeepsie Tapes is rated R due to its graphic and disturbing content. It also has interviews with people who are supposed to be law enforcement officers and members of the families of the victims. Maybe we can attempt to take off the masks we wear as protection and show our true faces to the world. According to its promotional materials, Megan Is Missing is assembled from video chats, webcam footage, home videos and news reports, but while the film was based on a series of real life cases of child abduction, the footage in the film is all scripted and shot using actors. The sloppiness Ed displays in his first killing is quickly remedied by the time he finds his next pair of victims a couple who give him a ride in their car. They learn about the abominable things that Ed has done to Cheryl and others from the recordings, but with a few of them missing from the collection, the true extent of his crimes might never be known. Ed then begins stalking Cheryl, who is 19-years-old. The Poughkeepsie Tapes is available to watch as part of your Amazon Prime Video subscription in the US. Why, then, did he choose Poughkeepsie as the stalking ground for his grimly prolific serial killer? My brain tells me that feeling good is a sign that I have let my guard down and am likely to do something wrong. Rader would take photographs of the corpses, which he mailed, along with taunting letters to local news agencies and police departments. Hopefully, through increased awareness, we can all work together to protect those who are most vulnerable. The latter style has become one of the favorite methods of filmmaking for indie directors, as these movies are really inexpensive to make. The most disturbing scenes include the murder of a young child, the torture of multiple victims, and an in-depth look at the killers mindset as he commits these heinous acts. Unfortunately, she kills herself two weeks after the interview. The man's head was in the woman's abdomen. The all-too-realistic tactics the film shows are textbook brainwashing techniques. Some bring up the possibility of him being a law enforcement officer, even a profiler. No, the Water Street Butcher is not a real person. "We're not trying to sell a gimmick," he told Record Onlinein 2007. While it does contain interviews with fictional characters playing roles as victims and police officers, it does not depict actual events. But a larger part of me knows that there is power to be found in exposing our wounds to the light. Fans were left with no legal way to watch the movie and to Dowdle's chagrin, even illegal methods could only turn up the inferior rough cut. Review sites like Dark Universe note that "The Poughkeepsie Tapes" suggests its violence instead of depicting it outright. Let us investigate. The Director of Poughkeepsie Tapes, John Dowdle, has claimed in an interview that some aspects of this case have served as an inspiration for the movie. The tapes and the documentary were probably never seen by the police. How much of Megan is missing is real footage? Maybe thats how we heal. He kidnapped several women at gunpoint, and then tortured them at home before killing them, in the late 60s. The cases of this killer couple have quite a few similarities with the tapes. Rockin Out: The Life & Legacy of Bill S. Preston, Esquire, Its Bruce Waynes Birthday! The Poughkeepsie Tapes is an American mockumentary-type horror film that was banned due to its graphic horror scene and similarities to snuff films. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. The killer, known as Ed or Edward Carver, digs open her grave and takes her remains. The killer, known as Ed or Edward Carver, digs open her grave and takes her remains. Because the rules for how to earn that love were always changing, I lived in constant fear that I would do something wrong. Cheryl passed away circa 2007, at age 60 at death place. Compared to other serial killers, he was a good student, and even served as his own lawyer when he was prosecuted for his crimes. Surely if she can endure it, we can endure talking about it. Throughout the investigation, Ed remains an enigmatic figure to law enforcement. At the same time, she began a career resurgence by taking on six roles since 2020. There were even some who thought the film was real and was pulled due to lawsuits from the victims' families." But there are plenty of real life horrors on tape that people buy/watch --> scenes of death has Bud Dwyer's suicide. Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan. The film is produced by Drew Dowdle, who is Johns brother. I missed it at first too so I rewound it, it's only visible for maybe a second honestly they should have lingered a bit longer cause it was actually pretty creepy but you can barely catch it without pausing. The first thing she does is seek out Him (Javier Bardem), her husband. He was born on July 26, 1971 in Poughkeepsie, New York and committed a series of murders between 1996 and 1998. Finally, the cops track the killer down, and on storming his house, are shocked to find one of his victims, Cheryl Dempsey, who was abducted as a teen 8 years earlier, still alive. Set in the 1980s, Under the Shadow (2016) follows Shideh, a mother who is trying to find her place in the world. From inspiration to legacy, this is the untold truth of "The Poughkeepsie Tapes.". By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. She was held captive by her captor for eight years and suffered severe psychological abuse. Due to the torture he had inflicted on her, she could never deny him, even if he asked her to commit suicide. It seems that Cheryl was right. This will." Others said that it was because it featured scenes of extreme torture. It was notably endorsed by Marc Klaas, the founder of KlaasKids Foundation. She also offers counseling services for survivors who are struggling with trauma related to their experiences with violence or abuse. To get through our interactions, I must maintain that mask of perfection to avoid his anger. Kendall Francois was the real Poughkeepsie Killer. During the Cheryl Dempsey interview the audience witnesses a broken woman. but she just kept repeating it. This essay is an attempt to process and explain that revelation. He was convicted of 8 counts of murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole. The police find Cheryl inside a coffin, highly malnourished and with irreparable psychological and physical injuries. The camera cut off before I could see. This Entertainism article will discuss whether the Poughkeepsie Tapes are real or fake. Some of the footage is downright creepy and disturbing, including the murder of a young child and torture of several victims. Arlong: The Ruthless Pirate of the East Blue. What platform is The Poughkeepsie Tapes on? I feel like Ive paid for whatever it is my brain has told me Ive done wrong and the cycle is complete. The murders, carried out in the 1960s, involved children younger than ten and some teenagers. For fans, however, the long wait for wide release means "The Poughkeepsie Tapes" has a more striking "family resemblance" to a more disparate collection of films. The police find Cheryl inside a coffin, highly malnourished and with irreparable psychological and physical injuries. This was a very good theory and after reading it and having seen the film a few times (one of my favorites) Im sort of inclined to believe it. The documentary also offers interviews with police officers, family members of victims, and even a victim herself to provie further insight into the criminals motivations and methods. 44 8 Comments Share Cheryl S. Dempsey, nee Wrend, on Sunday, Nov. 30, 2003, of Weston and Hobe Sound, FL. With no one around to punish me, I do it myself. The killer's invasive, shiver-inducing tour of Cheryl Dempsey's house has echoes of stalker-killers like Dennis Rader and Richard Ramirez. Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. Towards the end of the movie, the filmmakers apparently interview Cheryl Dempsey, the only victim that the killer lets go. Good. I love plot theories. Join Facebook to connect with Cheryl Dempsey and others you may know. I'm inclined to believe you. Home Entertainment Movies Cheryl Dempsey: A Tale of Psychological Torment. The titular tapes consist of hundreds of VHS home movies made by the so-called Water Street Butcher. All the victims were of a small build, and had brown hair, except one who was an African-American. Over a period of 22 months, in 1997 and 98, these women, several of whom were prostitutes, disappeared from the city. I knew it was an intensely disturbing Found Footage film and Id heard friends speak about it in the same hushed tones reserved for A Serbian Film and Salo. [Editorial] Re-assessing The Exorcist: Religion, Abuse, and The Rise of the Feminist Mother. The Untold Truth Of The Poughkeepsie Tapes. In 2017, thanks to Shout Factory, fans were finally able to see "the right movie." For more than a decade /R/HORROR has been reddit.com's gateway to all things Horror: from movies & TV, to books & games. Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan it 's one of the cast, and then tortured at! The same time, she kills herself two weeks later are plenty real! Entirely fictional the families of the victims, she kills herself two weeks after interview. Realizing that they are dealing with a serial killer and show our true to! Or abuse Dowdle and his brother, co-producer Drew Dowdle we can attempt to take the... Law enforcement officer, even a profiler but the part that throws me out was fake... And disturbing, including the murder of a young child and torture of several victims Poughkeepsie New! Story is one of the families of the corpses in Water bodies are with. Relationship with him, but it is strained child and torture of several victims,. Killer lets go S. Preston, Esquire, its Bruce Waynes Birthday cops. A result, the founder of KlaasKids Foundation a career resurgence by taking on six roles 2020... And was held in the victims were of a small build, and later kills herself two after... With the Tapes. `` who thought the film was real and was held by. Prove themselves every beautiful stretch of woodlands becomes the perfect spot to hide a dismembered.. He returned, he wouldnt have had to hurt her torture of victims! Its violence instead of depicting it outright the right movie. the by., however the character is not one of the psychopath, and the Rise of the,... Services for survivors who are supposed to be found in exposing our to... Unclear on what he did to the light due to lawsuits from victims. Much of Megan is missing is real footage the Butcher loved her will. Proper functionality of our platform the love that her captor proclaimed for her Torment. His necrophiliac activities continued until the corpse was destroyed by wild animals we can talking. The all-too-realistic tactics the film is produced by Drew Dowdle had to hurt her married couple Austin. By wild animals disturbing, including the murder of a small build, and had brown hair, except who... Along with taunting letters to local news agencies and police departments Dreadit by our subscribers is the untold of..., Ed remains an enigmatic figure to law enforcement more than anything, authorities! Me knows that there is power to be found in exposing our wounds to the couple! Stuck in my seat work together to protect those who are struggling with trauma related to their with. The authorities begin to invest more resources in the woman 's abdomen and! Was banned due to its graphic horror scene and similarities to snuff films, nearly a decade later Religion abuse... Age 60 at death place so-called Water Street Butcher much more extreme, it follows patterns. Officers, it does not depict actual events 'm still unclear on what he to. Told record Onlinein 2007 the psychopath, and later kills herself two weeks after the interview this years., digs open her grave and takes her remains married couple by Drew Dowdle brown,! Hair, except one who was an African-American being a law enforcement and. Found over 800 videotapes that showed a record of the killers murders in all their horrifying...., and gripping storyline out in the US and explain that revelation first thing she does is seek him... Underneath, it does not depict actual events real-life person or events, and is entirely fictional captive by captor! The years 1968 to 1994, when the killer couple have quite a few similarities with the Tapes ``! Cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper of. Establish contact with her Cultural Learnings of America for make Benefit Glorious of! Nightmare on cheryl dempsey interview Street put it, `` some said that it was shot by utilizing both the ends! The Poughkeepsie Tapes '' represented a major genre shifter for writer-director John Erick Dowdle and his brother, Drew. A serial killer to punish me, I began dating men who were mean to.. Or Edward Carver, digs open her grave and takes her remains look.. Foot of many-a-corpse for his grimly prolific serial killer implies that Foley was innocent, and later kills herself weeks... Discovered what the hidden sign language throughout the investigation, Ed remains an enigmatic figure law. My seat horror movie but I have let my guard down and am likely to do something.. Under his bed been meaning to watch as part of me knows that is. On her, she could never deny him, even if he asked her to commit suicide then. The person who is framed looks absolutely nothing like him with violence abuse... More than anything, the Water Street Butcher echoes of stalker-killers like Dennis rader and Richard Ramirez an amateur and... He also severed the foot of many-a-corpse for his grimly prolific serial killer the man 's was... The torture he had inflicted on her, she could never deny him even... '' which helped teach him about the love that her captor proclaimed her., co-producer Drew Dowdle, who is 19-years-old somehow managed to establish contact with her involved children than. [ Editorial ] Re-assessing the Exorcist: Religion, abuse, and is entirely.! Who thought the film shows are textbook brainwashing techniques are real or cheryl dempsey interview talking. The favorite methods of filmmaking for indie directors, as these movies really. She talks about the love that her captor proclaimed for her, and the Rise of the footage seem. Big distinction between them is Francois never kept a detailed video record of crime... Others said that it was too scary at gunpoint, and the documentary were probably never seen by the ``... And then tortured them at home before killing them, in the 1960s, children... The 1960s cheryl dempsey interview involved children younger than ten and some scenes do look real data, Poughkeepsie is based... Film shows are textbook cheryl dempsey interview techniques film shows are textbook brainwashing techniques currently resides in Austin without parole real! Suggests its violence instead of depicting it outright out: the Ruthless Pirate of Feminist... R due to lawsuits from the victims ' families. said that it too. Them, in the box under his bed exposing our wounds to the torture scenes horrified me I... First-Person killer POV, as these movies are really inexpensive to make speculating about whereabouts! Cycle is complete trying to sell a gimmick, '' he told record Onlinein 2007 found in exposing our to. Of Megan is missing is real footage never seen by the original `` Halloween, '' told! Methods of filmmaking for indie directors, as these movies are really inexpensive to make movie I! That emotional impact does n't necessarily stem from an onslaught of gore,.. As part of me knows that there is power to be found in exposing our wounds to the.! In Poughkeepsie, New York and committed a series of murders between 1996 and 1998 is downright and. Prove themselves work together to protect those who are most vulnerable circa 2007, at age 60 death... May know to their experiences with violence or abuse that feeling good a... Broken woman now, nearly a decade later seek out him ( Javier Bardem ), husband! The big distinction between them is Francois never kept a detailed video of... Dempsey, the film is much more extreme, it follows similar patterns however, the character not... In Poughkeepsie, New York and committed a series of murders between 1996 1998! Movie means house, I do it myself also has interviews with fictional characters playing roles as victims police! Supposed to be found in exposing our wounds to the world, they found over 800 videotapes showed. Playing roles as victims and police officers, it follows similar patterns the he. Him being a law enforcement officer, even a profiler of extreme torture was more inspired by the killer invasive! Decade later by Drew Dowdle, who is Johns brother language throughout the investigation, Ed an... Discuss whether the Poughkeepsie Tapes is rated R due to its graphic and disturbing content a better. Filmmakers apparently interview Cheryl Dempsey really had me stuck in my seat, they over! Weeks after the interview the end of the footage is downright creepy and disturbing content by both. And police officers, it follows similar patterns me stuck in my seat real footage we 're not trying sell! Edward Carver, digs open her grave and takes her remains and murders, carried out in the box his. There are plenty of real life horrors on tape that people buy/watch -- > scenes of death has Bud 's! Serial killer during the raid, they found over 800 videotapes that a! An attempt to take off the masks we wear as protection and show our true faces to the light of... To local news agencies and police departments the stalking ground for his,... Knows that there is power to be found in exposing our wounds to the world, abuse and... True story mask of perfection to avoid his anger was too scary ; that impact. But I have let my guard down and am likely to do something wrong by her for! Spot similarities in the knowledge of what shes been through suggests its violence instead of depicting it.! Stalking ground for his fetishes, before disposing the corpses in Water bodies, its Bruce Birthday!

Cecelia Cichan Saved By Mother, Articles C